"IF YOU LIKE GOLF"

online golf column
by
Chris Dortch

July 21, 2009

Did Tom Watson lose the British Open or did Stewart Cink win it? That was the question among golf fans the world over after the 59-year-old Watson came within a stroke of the most significant achievement in the history of sports.

Before I continue, full disclosure is in order. Tom Watson is one of my all-time favorite players and I was more disappointed after his loss in a four-hole playoff to Cink than I’ve been after any golf tournament I’ve ever covered, watched on television or heard about.

Now that that’s out of the way, it’s safe to say the answer to the question is twofold. Yes, Cink, one of the best guys who ever drew back a club and a player of extraordinary skill, did what he had to do to win at historic Turnberry. His 12-foot birdie putt at the 18th was clutch, and he dominated a clearly drained Watson in the four-hole playoff.

And alas, Watson contributed to his demise with his inability to get up and down from behind the 18th green. One of the best scramblers in golf history couldn’t make the most important par save of his life, and for that, golf fans everywhere feel like I do.

It’s a helluva game, golf. Watson is allowed to bask in old glories all week at Turnberry, where he out-dueled the great Jack Nicklaus for an Open championship in 1977. And then, when he’s at the brink of becoming the oldest player in history to win a major championship, a six-time Open winner and tied for fourth all-time with nine majors, he’s beaten back down, felled by a long-time nemesis. His 10-foot putt to save par at Turnberry’s 18th never had a chance, as though Watson were hoping it would go in rather than trying to make it go in.

Does this qualify Watson as a choker, as some on Facebook and Twitter proclaimed? Absolutely not. Anyone who’s played the game at any level knows he’s a great champion and didn’t choke.

The fates, it seemed, or the golfing gods, merely conspired against him.

How else to explain his last 8-iron approach to the 18th? Watson absolutely smashed that shot, but the ball just wouldn’t hold the green. Had it landed a mere foot short of where it did, Watson could have two-putted his way into golfing immortality.

As it was, Watson’s ball rolled off the green and nestled in the fringe. His short game philosophy (I know, I bought his short-game book back in his heyday) has always been that his worst putt is better than his worst chip. Perhaps that’s been true most of his career, but on Sunday, it wasn’t. The putt skidded 10 feet past the hole.

Could Watson have saved par by chipping? Should he have pulled a 9-iron from the fairway as he mentioned in his post-match press conference? Those questions will be debated long and hard, and poor Watson will carry them to his grave.

I don’t think I’ve ever pulled any harder for an athlete or a team to win. Millions of others could make that claim. Unfortunately, the collective will of golf fans around the world couldn’t help get Watson over the edge.

What’s most disappointing about Watson’s sudden demise at Turnberry was the fact that he’s two months from his 60th birthday. We know, and he probably does too, that this was his last hurrah competing against the world’s best players on the world’s greatest stage.

The stars seemed to be aligned perfectly for Watson: Tiger Woods missed the cut at a major for just the second time in his career. The tournament was played at a course Watson knows well and has won on before. And, with five Open championships and three Senior British Open titles on his resume, he’d have to be considered the greatest links player ever. This seemed to be his time, age be damned.

Regardless of whether Sunday was Watson’s last hurrah, the thrills he gave us during his improbable quest will long be remembered, and once again clearly illustrates that golf is a game for a lifetime.

###

*** Feedback ***
click here to give me your comments about this article,
 or suggest a subject for a future article