| 1962 | Lew Oehmig | 208 |
| 1963 | Banjie Goodman | 215 |
| 1964 | Ed Brantly | 201 |
| 1965 | Ed Brantly | 209 |
| 1966 | Larry White | 210 |
| 1967 | Ed Trimble | 207 |
| 1968 | John Richard, Jr. | 213 |
| 1969 | Larry White | 207 |
| 1970 | NO TOURNAMENT | |
| 1971 | NO TOURNAMENT | |
| 1972 | NO TOURNAMENT | |
| 1973 | NO TOURNAMENT | |
| 1974 | NO TOURNAMENT | |
| 1975 | NO TOURNAMENT | |
| 1976 | NO TOURNAMENT | |
| 1977 | Harold Lane | 217 |
| 1978 | Harold Lane | 213 |
| 1979 | Lew Oehmig | 214 |
| 1980 | Kip Henley | 209 |
| 1981 | Ed Brantly | 210 |
| 1982 | Harold Lane | 214 |
| 1983 | Chris Byrd | 217 |
| 1984 | Charlie Taylor, Jr. | 212 |
| 1985 | Ed Brantly | 211 |
| 1986 | Ed Brantly | 210 |